
Advancing Pretrial Justice
Training Pretrial Staff in San Francisco

Project Context:
- The San Francisco Pretrial Diversion Project (SF Pretrial) provides community-based programs for recently arrested people, managing an average daily caseload of 1,800 clients. It provides case management, in-house services such as clinical social workers, referrals to stabilization housing, and connections to external treatment providers.
- Judges in the San Francisco District Court requested that SF Pretrial share more nuanced data, such as side-by-side visualizations of safety rates and risk scores, which could help inform release decisions.
- Judges also requested more consistent data on pretrial outcomes to track the public safety and court appearance impacts of pretrial supervision decisions.
- SF Pretrial routinely collects and analyzes client data, but did not have a sustainable pipeline of data visualizations for judges to review.
- The GPL provided a tailored training series on data-driven performance management to SF Pretrial staff in 2024 and then began providing more robust technical assistance through our 2024 Pretrial Initiative.
How the GPL is Supporting:
- Training pretrial staff on data-driven performance management, including measuring output indicators (i.e., program activities) and outcome indicators (i.e., program results).
- Coaching pretrial staff on communicating key data points to help judges and other pretrial stakeholders better understand pretrial outcomes, such as developing a data dashboard and creating a plan to disseminate it.
My key takeaways from this training are that there are often many different interpretations of data, and one needs to be prepared when presenting data to judges. In the future, I would love to use data analysis techniques internally to identify trends, such as court appearance rates or re-arrest rates, and make program adjustments.Erik Crawford
Own Recognizance Assistance Manager, SF Pretrial
See Blog
